Wednesday, July 29, 2009

Intercontinental Bank’s Unhappy Customer

Mrs. Naomi Essien is a customer of Intercontinental Bank, Toyin Street Branch in Lagos. Sometime in November last year, one of her customers paid some money into her IPSA account but made the payment from another branch in Oregun, Lagos. About a month later, Mrs Essien went to the bank and requested for her account balance and unsatisfied with the figures, she requested for a print out of her account. That began an ordeal that is still unresolved as at press time.

The print out revealed that the payment was not reflected in her account. She raised the issue with the Acting Operations Manager who contacted the branch where the payment was made and she was asked to come back the next day. When she returned to her branch, she was told the payment was ‘hanging’ and he had resolved the issue. He then printed another statement of account for her. However, this new statement was significantly different from the earlier one she got just a few days earlier.

This new statement had been altered as far back as September though the disputed payment was made in November. She also noted that her balance didn’t change in spite of the adjustments to the transactions on her account so in effect; there was still no satisfactory explanation for the disputed payment.

Concerned about her money, Mrs Essien sought a resolution to this issue at her branch for months but no one could explain what really happened. In frustration, she sent a complaint to the bank’s headquarters a few weeks ago. She received a letter from the customer care department promising to investigate and get back to her. That was more than two weeks ago.

My Comments.

This customer’s complaint raises some core issues that borders on trust and confidence in banking transactions. A third party makes a deposit in a customer’s account and for over 2 weeks, that transaction did not reflect in the account and the bank was unaware until the customer complained. What happened to simple book keeping principles of balancing accounts at close of business?

The term ‘hanging’ is quite novel to me but I guess it must be common to bankers. How do you post a transaction to a specific account and it never gets there? Where was the money ‘hanging’? In financial cyberspace? What if Mrs Essien was like me and, I am sure, millions of customers who don’t bother to check the transactions on their accounts? Would the money have ‘hanged’ forever? One cannot help but wonder how many millions of naira are ‘hanging’ in financial cyberspace without the affected customers’ knowledge?

This case also highlights the challenges the banking industry seems to be having with technology in banking service. Or how does one explain how two print outs of the same account within one week reflect such disparity that is backdated two months before the disputed transaction was made? Did the computer make the errors two months earlier in anticipation of the ‘hanging’ transaction? Or someone trying to cover their tracks tampers with the account records when the customer raised the alarm? Only Intercontinental Bank can clear this for the customer and now, because of this publication, the millions of customers reading this piece.


The length of time it has taken the bank to resolve this issue is quite disappointing. Mrs Essien had complained to me since February but I had been reluctant to take it up because I knew she had engaged the customer service structure so I expected the issue to be resolved then. It does nothing for the bank’s customer care culture that five months since she first made the complaint, she still has not received any satisfactory resolution. Would the bank pay her interest on funds for the period it has been unaccounted for? Most likely not.

For a bank that hinges its communication strategy on being happy only when its customers are happy, one wonders how much unhappiness Intercontinental has suffered in sympathy with Mrs Essien’s apparent unhappiness with her relationship with the bank. It is easy to run campaigns eulogizing the customer like most banks do but talk is cheap. Unless service providers demonstrate their commitment to the customer in practical terms, one customer at a time, there will always be a disconnect between both parties; which results in complaints like this. A five-month-old complaint still being investigated belongs in the league of the police force and federal civil service where bureaucracy reigns supreme, not in the culture of a bank.

I decided to publish this complaint so as to alert other customers to be more aware of the transactions on their accounts. If we are going to evolve a more effective consumer protection environment in Nigeria, consumers will also need to take an active part in the process. If you are not too good with figures, please hire an accountant to run periodic checks on your bank accounts to ensure that similar issues are not happening to you unawares. There are so many porous ways in which service providers fleece their customers and though this might not be the case here, imagine if it was actually a planned strategy (like the telecoms industry seem to have perfected as we will be sharing here soon).

‘Wonder’ Charges: Skye Bank too!
On April 24, I published the complaint of a customer against UBA’s cash handling charges practice. I have since discovered that the practice is not limited to UBA alone as it seems practically all the banks are guilty of this questionable practice. I have also received similar complaints from many more customers confirming the growing displeasure to this extraneous and unjustifiable additional expense. To underscore this is this incredible story of a customer’s experience with Skye Bank, Allen Branch. The customer, Tony (he asked to keep his name out of print for business purposes) wanted to transfer the sum of N10m from GTBank to Skye Bank. He called his account officer to let him know that he would be making an interbank transfer which would take a few days to reflect in his Skye Bank account.

His account officer, eager to boost his bottom line, begged him to cash the money and bring it to the bank in cash so it can be lodged in as transaction for that day and he obliged him. One can only imagine his shock when he got his bank statement and discovered a charge of N25, 000 as “cash handling charges” for the transaction! At no point was he informed of any charges for the transaction and he has disputed the charge but the bank is not budging.

I also heard that some banks, trying to encourage the use of the ATM now charge “cash handling fees” on cash withdrawals over the counter of more than N100k. They conveniently forget that the ATM is programmed to dispense a maximum of 20k per transaction. And most ATMs charge N100 per transaction so that means an extra N500 for withdrawing 100k. So customers are forced to pay for withdrawing cash indirectly; not to mention the time wasted conducting 5 ATM transactions to get the desired amount. By the way, it is only in Nigeria that I have heard that customers are forced to use a particular mode of transaction. Whatever happened to choice and preferences?

Obviously, the banking industry is more concerned with its convenience and making profits and least bothered with the customer’s convenience or cost. While we acknowledge that we run the capitalist system, it is unacceptable that service providers like the banks are given a free reign on how and what they charge their customers when the Central Bank just looks on. Whose interests should the Central Bank be protecting; the banks it is regulating or the Nigerian consumer to whom the government should be accountable? (Oops! I almost forgot that governments in Nigeria are accountable only to themselves and the cabals that rig them into power.) Prof Soludo’s unhealthy closeness to the banks he is supposed to be regulating seems to be blurring his oversight of their activities in regular banking transactions. Meanwhile, the customer s are the multiple losers while the banks declare profits in billions.

This ‘cash handling charges’ is unacceptable and I believe this is time to test the system. I am thus advocating for a class action to challenge this practice. If you have a similar dispute with your bank, please get in touch so we can seek legal counsel on how best to pull together to challenge the concerned banks and Central Bank if necessary on this unjustifiable levy after all, there is still a Consumer Protection Act in this country.

Re: UBA’s Wonder Charges
I got a call from UBA on the above story and promised to publish their response to the complaint if they sent one. I am still waiting. Meanwhile, it is surprising that no one has contacted the customer who complained to date, at least not officially. Maybe UBA is really not concerned about what we think of them anymore. One wonders who wants to do business with a service provider who thinks our perception or opinion of them is immaterial. Tut tut, UBA, not impressive customer care response at all.

Our Power Dilemma

Like every Nigerian, I am at my wits end with this power situation. We have watched helplessly as the situation degenerated from bad to worse, bordering on an epidemic of incomparable proportions now. Elite and peasant alike, we have deliberated on why Nigeria seems jinxed about power. Our experts have postulated theories and positions on how to get us past this literally dark alley.

Our presidents have set up committees and special task forces to tackle this monster for decades now. After a seemingly unending parade of special advisers, ministers and consultants by one administration after the other, it is pathetic that in June 2009, we are still firmly in the grip of inadequate power supply.

Every Nigerian, irrespective of social or economic status has found some creative way to stave off the damning effect of this unwieldy situation. Many like me, have multiple generators; others graduated to inverters, “I beta pass my neighbor” is so common, it has ceased to be true to its name; every neighbor also has one now. The sounds of generating sets have become part of our environmental identity. The fumes from ageing or overworked engines gradually eke years off our life span. According to some statistics, the installed capacity of generators in Nigeria is about 18,000 megawatts: public power is currently just a little over 2000 megawatts!

Businesses close down regularly from the weight of diesel costs; manufacturing is fast disappearing from the Nigerian landscape. Icons of our national commerce history are relocating to more stable and predictable business environments like Ghana; the brave ones still operating here pass the costs straight to the consumer. The Nigerian consumers are the multiple losers in this scenario. On every front, the power palaver is costing us enormously, directly and indirectly, on the home front, business front and in basic lifestyle. Unfortunately, there does not seem to be an end in sight.

The few Nigerians who understand the issues tell you it is complicated. I have spoken to national advisers, consultants, employers and employees in the power sector for years now. By the time they weave the intricate web of prevailing issues, you become just as confused as they all appear to be. The list of what is responsible range from environmental, economic, infrastructural, political and communal issues to simple matters like consumer ignorance, carelessness and of course, Nigeria’s greatest enemy, the demon of corruption and individual greed.

In a national crisis like this, a focused and visionary administration will display the political will to break this stronghold on our national psyche. I recall the president, as a candidate then, promising to declare a state of national emergency on the power issue. Almost two years into his presidency, we are still awaiting that declaration. A responsive and responsible government will prioritize the well being of its citizens above all other interests but it appears like the “interests” are more in power than the president.

Ethnic, political, religious and personal interests are reigning roughshod over the Nigerian state and they seem to dictate the decisions that affect the rest of us. There are conspiracy theories making the rounds that the cartel that import generators and diesel are part of the saboteurs of national efforts to rectify the situation. The dilemma here is that key members of this purported cartel are core financial members of the ruling party PDP so how can we expect the president to rein them in when he who pays the piper dictates the tune?

Then there is the Northern oligarchy’s interest in the issue. According to this theory, the Northern power sharks are resisting the functional unbundling of PHCN such that distribution infrastructure can be ceded to relevant states which would enable such states to generate and distribute their own power. If we recall the Lagos Enron Project hullabaloo, the Federal Government had insisted on invoking an obviously obsolete clause in the Constitution that cedes power distribution exclusively to them. Lagos State was then expected to generate its power but add it to the national grid thus power generated by Lagos State could be distributed in Jigawa or Ebonyi State.

Well, political observers maintain that the privatization of national structures seem to have left the Northern oligarchy on the sidelines of power so in order not to lose out completely, they are resisting the PHCN move to enable them remain relevant in the national structure. In simple English, Nigeria is being held to ransom by a select few who are afraid to lose their political relevance. If this conspiracy theory is accurate, then the purported cabal would rather sacrifice the lives and livelihoods of Nigerians on the altar of political relevance. Unfortunately, the president may be unable to rein this interest in either since he would naturally belong to the purported Northern oligarchy, if any does exist that is.

The infrastructural challenges are worth mentioning too. As we speak, there are loads of power turbines languishing at Nigerian ports mainly because it is practically impossible to transport them to their intended locations. Why? Our roads are grossly inadequate. One of the IPPs based in the east had narrated the story of its turbines at a round table conference on power I attended late last year.

According to him, there was a bridge along the course of the transfer that has capacity to withstand just ten tons or so but the turbines weighed more than twice that much. When the relevant authorities were approached to construct a heavier bridge, they were told it was not on budget, the IPP then offered to construct same at its expense but was flatly refused the permission. Of course that delayed the project lead time for months before they decided to put up temporary reinforcement s for the turbine to cross the bridge.

This situation is a classic example of the ripple effect of bad management and lack of visionary planning. Our current power situation is obviously a consequence of past military years of gross negligence, greed, ignorance and selfish aggrandizement. If those juntas had an inch of patriotic bone in their bodies, they would have improved on our infrastructure when Nigeria was rich enough to pay for it. Rather they focused on updating their personal financial empires. At least one of them is still alive to feel the impact of his error in judgment. No matter how many generators the ‘evil genius’ installs in his fortress on the hill, he is equal to every one of us, (e no beta pass him neighbor!)

Another strand of the power knot is the reported cases of communal or individual greed. Communities have been known to extort money incessantly from IPPs situating in their localities. Our sense of communal and national responsibility has been so eroded that every ma n or community is interested in what is in it for them. Maybe if such communities were shown the unending possibilities such projects bring in tourism, jobs, and infrastructural development, this particular issue could be managed. I understand there is a power plant in Ghana where tourists pay as much as $20 each to see. Nigerians are among the visitors too.

After pondering on the possible causes and theories responsible for where we are, where do we go from here? That is the trillion dollar question. How do we bring this situation under control once and for all? Paraphrasing Mitchell, the U.S Middle East envoy, ‘every conflict (or crises) created by humans can be resolved by humans”. No human created problem is impossible to solve. Nigeria’s power crisis is manmade and so can be man solved. The singular most important ingredient in resolving this situation is the political and executive will to do so. If President Yar’adua really wants to give Nigerians power, he needs to declare the promised state of emergency in the power sector with immediate effect.

The declaration of an emergency will enable him to bypass constitutional structures that hinder proactive decisions to move us forward. We have sought a national response to the situation for decades now to no avail. It is time to seek state, regional or individual household solutions. We must be committed to try anything that works, even if it has never been done before as this is the time to think outside the box. I saw a model for solar power that seems practicable and affordable for households at the recent Oxford University African Business Conference in UK early last month. But will the existing power legislation be flexible enough to enable Nigerians seek such an alternative?

Aso Rock needs to acknowledge that it does not have all the answers and seek the simple wisdom of the average Nigerian; who knows if the rural wisdom of a farmer might resolve the community issues, or a poor young inventor might come up with a unique model that would work within our peculiar circumstance. The Yar’adua administration needs to engage the Nigerian society in resolving this crisis as we all need a sense of national urgency to save our society from collapse or else, we would have proven Lord Lugard, the inadvertent founder of our nation, right in his scathing but sadly accurate evaluation of the African species (obviously using Nigerians as a sample of the black African race) with which I close this piece.

"In character and temperament" wrote Lord Lugard, "the typical African (read Nigerian) … is a happy, thriftless, excitable person, lacking in self control, discipline, and foresight. Naturally courageous, and naturally courteous and polite, full of personal vanity, with little sense of veracity, fond of music… His thoughts are concentrated on the events and feelings of the moment, and he suffers little from the apprehension for the future or grief for the past.

His mind is far nearer to the animal world than that of the European or Asiatic, and exhibits something of the animal’s placidity and want of desire to rise beyond the state he has reached… He lacks the power of organisation, and is conspicuously deficient in the management and control alike of men or business.

He loves the display of power, but fails to realize its responsibility.... Perhaps the two traits which have impressed me as those most characteristic of the African native are his lack of apprehension and his in ability to visualize the future" P g 70 of The Dual Mandate by F.D.Lugard 1926.